It is quite unusual to find a book that is a collection of
articles and essays as page turning as “What Does It Mean to Be Well Educated?”
written by Alphie Kohn. As I was
reading, I found myself becoming excited by Kohn's ideas.
When Kohn has an idea he takes it, runs with it, and never
looks back. His book is thoroughly researched, but what I really enjoyed about
this book is that it is the only book I have read that so blatantly showed such
a defiance to the public school system as it currently is. Kohn has so much
research backing him up, as well as plenty of moving testimonials, as to why
the public school system is in desperate need of reform.
Kohn suggests separating the public school system not only
of standardized tests and college entrance tests (ex. SAT), but of grades as
well. He does a great job of presenting
his arguments with good research as well as what he believes the alternatives
should be, and does it all in an easily readable manner. One of the most
important statements in this book, in my opinion, is when Kohn says, “Grades
tend to reduce students interest in the learning itself.”(section 9) This is true on so
many levels. I know that in many of my classes, I am so focused on the grading
that I just “follow the rubric”. When I am actually interested in a subject, I
tend to do worse in the class because I go off on my own and really get into
what I am learning and forget about the assigned objectives for the class at
the time.
I did feel like at times that Kohn may have gone a bit too
extreme on some topics. His chapter on how saying "good job" to children
is actually detrimental may have gone a bit too far. At the same time, even though
I felt the chapter became a little ridiculous, there were still many very valid
arguments made and research presented. Despite disagreeing to an extent, I
truly learned and thought about something I had never considered before, which
I think it the point of the book.
“What Does It Mean To Be Well Educated?” is a perfect read
for teachers wanting ideas to make their classrooms more education friendly,
students who are fed up with all the pressures of standardized tests and
grades, and administrators looking to
improve their school on their own standards.
Even though I disagreed with some of Kohn’s ideas, I feel
that this book is an excellent read. It made me think about how I would one day
like to teach my kids and about what I would like my curriculum to be as a teacher.
It showed me the importance of know what is important in my classroom and also
showed me that the way our schools are today is not good for a younger
generations. It is amazing to me that this book was written eight years ago and
still nothing has changed in the education world today. How can so much time
pass and we are still focused on what could be and what should be with our school
systems?