Sunday, April 22, 2012

What Does it Mean to be Well Educated?


It is quite unusual to find a book that is a collection of articles and essays as page turning as “What Does It Mean to Be Well Educated?”  written by Alphie Kohn. As I was reading, I found myself becoming excited by Kohn's ideas.

When Kohn has an idea he takes it, runs with it, and never looks back. His book is thoroughly researched, but what I really enjoyed about this book is that it is the only book I have read that so blatantly showed such a defiance to the public school system as it currently is. Kohn has so much research backing him up, as well as plenty of moving testimonials, as to why the public school system is in desperate need of reform.

Kohn suggests separating the public school system not only of standardized tests and college entrance tests (ex. SAT), but of grades as well.  He does a great job of presenting his arguments with good research as well as what he believes the alternatives should be, and does it all in an easily readable manner. One of the most important statements in this book, in my opinion, is when Kohn says, “Grades tend to reduce students interest in the learning itself.”(section 9) This is true on so many levels. I know that in many of my classes, I am so focused on the grading that I just “follow the rubric”. When I am actually interested in a subject, I tend to do worse in the class because I go off on my own and really get into what I am learning and forget about the assigned objectives for the class at the time.

I did feel like at times that Kohn may have gone a bit too extreme on some topics. His chapter on how saying "good job" to children is actually detrimental may have gone a bit too far. At the same time, even though I felt the chapter became a little ridiculous, there were still many very valid arguments made and research presented. Despite disagreeing to an extent, I truly learned and thought about something I had never considered before, which I think it the point of the book.

“What Does It Mean To Be Well Educated?” is a perfect read for teachers wanting ideas to make their classrooms more education friendly, students who are fed up with all the pressures of standardized tests and grades, and  administrators looking to improve their school on their own standards.

Even though I disagreed with some of Kohn’s ideas, I feel that this book is an excellent read. It made me think about how I would one day like to teach my kids and about what I would like my curriculum to be as a teacher. It showed me the importance of know what is important in my classroom and also showed me that the way our schools are today is not good for a younger generations. It is amazing to me that this book was written eight years ago and still nothing has changed in the education world today. How can so much time pass and we are still focused on what could be and what should be with our school systems?

Monday, April 2, 2012

Blog 2...Sexual Orientaion


Upon starting this presentation with Holli, I felt very confident in my knowledge in the differences of sexual orientation that are around me every day. I still feel that I know much more about the different orientation that most people and feel good about that.

Whenever we started digging deeper into the bullying aspect of sexual orientation, I started to feel less confident in the knowledge I possessed. There are many new studies out now that lead people to believe that sexual orientation is more innate, just like being left handed or right handed, than it is a preference or choice. While I believe that this is true, I also believe that you can change it if you work hard enough. For example, it is possible to teach yourself to write with your left hand even if you were born right handed. I feel that if it is your religious outlook that homosexuality, bisexuality, or Tran sexuality is wrong then there is something that you can do about it as a person with those feelings. That being said, I very strongly feel that regardless of how someone portrays him or herself or what their sexual preference, it is no one else’s place to judge them. So, whether or not someone is a different sexual orientation than you has no effect on you whatsoever and therefore is none of your business.

I found the statistics found on bullying and suicide with LGBT teens appalling. To think that someone could make another person feel so poor about themselves that they would consider or even act out suicide is outrageous to me. How does someone live with that kind of guilt for the rest of their life? I know I couldn’t. There are many things that other people do or ways that other people choose to live that I completely disagree with but I cannot imagine something that I disagree with because it affects me to the point of bullying another person. I feel that there should be more support groups for victims of bullying in our society.

Monday, January 30, 2012

BLOG POST 1

 I believe that there are a few factors that can change a person’s educational philosophy as a teacher.  First, as a person grows as an educator and gains more experience, his or her philosophy can change; secondly, the grade level and age of the children that a person is teaching determines what philosophy a person may or may not have and lastly, depending on the children’s personalities that you have each year may change how you want to convey the information to the students.  This being said, I feel that I am a mix between the teaching styles of progressivism and essentialism.
         I believe as a progressivist, that students learn better by working in groups, and hands on learning.   Students may learn more if they help each other to work out the various problems they are given.  I have had many teachers throughout my education that seem to be progressivists. .  I recall all of the times that a teacher would teach a lesson and then let us break into groups to work on an activity that furthered our knowledge on the subject. These teachers would expect the students to solve our own problems and would not just give away the answers.  This helped students work through and attain better problem solving skills rather than always relying on someone else to figure the answer out if the student could not get it immediately. It also helped students bounce ideas off one another and help to expand one another’s knowledge base. 
         An essentialist teacher conveys knowledge to the students.  He or she believes lectures and recitations are what are needed to help students learn.  He or she also believes in the “three R’s”.  I feel that reading, writing, and arithmetic are very important. Sometimes if you gets too hands on in a classroom or use too much group work, the children may start to lose attention or begin not focusing on the subject at hand anymore. This happens more often when you are dealing with younger children.  This is why there are some classes that I feel have to be taught in an essentialist manner.  This is why essentialism is important.
         Although classes such as science and math are easily taught as hands-on projects, other subjects like History and Philosophy are not as easily taught in this nature. It may be easier for the teacher to convey the message through lecture. It also may be easier for the student to understand through lecture rather than trying to force hands on activities with a difficult subject.  I feel that both of the schools of philosophy that were discussed are very important. While they are very different, they are both very effective in most cases.